*****

*****
The Writer's Spotlight is proud to present the Author for September:
Silver Ink Pot
Biography: My name is Jeanne Kimsey, although in Harry Potter Fandom I have other nicknames: Silver Ink Pot or SIP for short, and Rattlesnakeroot on Livejournal. I think some people are born to attract nicknames and that would be me.
I grew up in Chattanooga, Tennessee, with a large family and a house full of old books. My mother was a big reader - books, newspapers, National Geographic, the Sears Catalog, house plan books from the hardware - anything. She would read whatever we kids were reading for school, or our library books, and I guess I'm just like her because I found Harry Potter when my daughter asked for the books after seeing them at school.
English was always my best subject in school, and then I studied English Literature and Language at the University of TN at Chattanooga. I learned how to write a good essay. Criticism, however, was not my first love.
I started out writing poetry while still in high school, and when I was a senior I had a poem accepted by Seventeen magazine. It was the most exciting thing that had ever happened to me. Later in college I was published in the school literary magazine, and became the Editor by my senior year. I took workshop classes in Poetry writing, and then worked towards a Masters of Fine Arts in Creative Writing at the Univ. of Alabama. But I realized pretty fast that in the U.S. there isn't much of a future in poetry, unless you want to float around from place to place as a guest writer for half your life, which I definitely did not see myself doing.
I came home very disillusioned, but pulled myself together and became a workaholic as a tutor at a private school, working for a monthly art museum newsletter, and then as a librarian. In the midst of all that, I met my husband in 1984 while he was still a student. Our first home was a run-down apartment building on the Tennessee River where we lived for 8 years. We had two children, then moved to our present little house in the country. Later we had a third child and my world became really small and child-centered for years.
I had plenty of time to read, but most of the time I couldn't find a novel that I liked. Every book seemed to have uninteresting characters and depressing endings. So when I discovered the Harry Potter books, with their message of hope and magic, I was entranced. I was amazed they actually got into print, since so much of children's literature today tries to be "important" and therefore, negative. After four books I was a big fan, and after the fifth book, Order of the Phoenix, came out in 2003, I was obsessed and joined a forum to find some answers.
Nothing I had ever done prepared me for the indignities of Fandom. I wasted a lot of time on silly threads comparing the Marauders to the Beatles, and deciphering the hidden anagrams in “Droobles Best Blowing Gum.” We “Deconstructed” the Marauders” in circular arguments that are still floating around in the atmosphere somewhere over the Pacific Ocean.
It was fun, but eventually I discovered “Development of Snape’s Character through Order of the Phoenix.” Suddenly there were serious topics to discuss: bullying, cliques, appearance versus reality, respect, and trust. And there were other people in the world who wanted to discuss the books as literature and find the clues in references to mythology, alchemy, poetry, plays, novels, and even songs. I was at home in that world, and that’s where I’ve been in ever since. To find a community of like-minded people is the greatest gift of modern technology. I can't even express what some of my friends have done to expand my world.
In early 2004, the website Mugglenet in connection with Wizarding World Press started a “writing opportunity” for the fans to get some of the favorite theories into print in a book that would later be called The Plot Thickens: Harry Potter Investigated for Fans by Fans. I had several theories that didn’t quite fit on the forums, but I wasn’t sure if I could write a coherent essay about them. I entered four ideas into the contest and all four were taken, much to my surprise. It’s funny to look back at that time because I did not have much confidence in myself as a writer. My computer died during the editing, and my final drafts were written in longhand at the kitchen table and typed at the library. I had never saved anything to a floppy disc before. I had never emailed a document before. I had to download my contract at the library and then hurry home to cook supper. I didn’t think I would ever get something finished and into print, but I did.
Nothing ever seemed quite that hard to write again. Sometimes I would be inspired by all my great friends here on HPN or CoS, and an essay would almost write itself. I had several more essays posted on Mugglenet Editorials, and wrote in a frenzy here on HPN just before Deathly Hallows was released.
After that I started writing weekly entries in my Livejournal "The Illuminated Dungeon" which gained quite a following because of the HP Lexicon Trial. I love the freedom of being a blogger because you are the Moderator of your own destiny. It's another great place to practice writing and to sharpen your arguments.
In the Fall of 2007 I was approached to work on a book for Mugglenet again. We worked on that for a year, and the manuscript became Harry Potter Should have Died, which was a true labor of love. It was a privilege and blessing to get to work with Ulysses Press and to get to know Emerson Spartz and Ben Schoen. It was like working on any book – sometimes it was lonely, sometimes stressful, sometimes depressing considering the theme of death that pervades Deathly Hallows. But the goal was to create something irreverent, fiesty, and thought-provoking that fans would enjoy. We wanted to remind people that not all the questions have easy answers and that Fandom is still going strong.
So that’s my long-winded story. I don’t know the secrets of writing a good essay except to be passionate about a topic, use interesting language, try to have a sense of humor, and make it personal. Don’t ride the fence too much – it gets painful after a while. Don’t be afraid to take a stand on an issue, even if people release the hounds on you. Be brave. Bring up something that makes someone else uncomfortable. Play Devil's Advocate. It’s OK to be wrong, but
don’t ever become boring.
*****

*****
Bibliography: On Mugglenet:
Mugglenet Editorials ~ Horace Slughorn's Slippery NameMugglenet Editorials ~ Dumbledore and the Tantalizing Tantalus ClueOn Harry Potter Network:
Apothecary Snape: Potions, Medicine, Alchemy, HealingBullying in the Books: Some Wounds Run Too Deep for HealingEssence of Asphodel: Lily Evans Potter and the Poetic TraditionGreen Light on the Tower: Illuminating What Really HappenedThe Harry Filter Phenomenon: Sometimes It Works Too WellThe Hippogriff Symbol and Severus Snape: Keeping an Eye on the ImpossibleThe Importance of Being LunaJames Potter: Reformed Bad Boy?Mithras Victorious: Severus, Harry, and the God of Roman SoldiersWas Groupthink the Downfall of the Marauders?The Harry Potter Lexicon Lawsuit: Fair Use and Andy Warhol's Soup CansHow Would Harry Potter Judge Susan Boyle?On Livejournal:
Snape Victorious As a Human BeingDear Ms. Rowling, What About My Good Guy Syndrome?The Parseltongue News ~ Vindictive EditionWord Ownership: Who Invented the Slithy Snarky Slytherin Snorkack?The Search for Alohomora ~ FoundWelcome to NarcissaCastFiction:
Ask SnapeSnape's Summer Cruise Part II: The Voyage of the Cocktail KillerDeathly Hallows Epilogue: Those FieldsLily's Mysterious Mood SwingHow I Spent My Summer Vacation: Dear Old Dog DaysBooks:
The Plot Thickens: Harry Potter Investigated By Fans for FansMugglenet's Harry Potter Should Have Died*****

*****
Questions and Answers
While working on ‘Harry Potter Should Have Died’, did any of the questions you researched change your mind about something you’d interpreted differently in the series?
I became less thrilled about the Elder Wand plot, because when you really study it, there are some serious questions about whether JKR broker her own rule of "love over magic" theme found in the rest of the series. That was probably my biggest revelation and a bit of a disappointment: that magic really did save Harry after all, more than love. Snape's love became much more important, in my opinion, than Lily's love for Harry, or his love for everyone else. Snape's love and asking Voldemort to show Lily mercy gave her a choice to live or die, and that protected Harry. Later, Harry chose to sacrifice himself, again due to Snape's memories, but at the moment Harry "died, he was all ready Master of the Wand, had used the Stone, and had the Cloak. He was basically invincible.
So no matter how many times JKR protests the idea of a deux ex machina, it's there. The magical blood saved him, but so did the Elder Wand. As a plot device it had nothing to do with Lily's love or her blood, although I guess technically Harry's goodness makes him "worthy" to be Master of the Deathly Hallows. But there again - the Wand only sees power, and it's a stretch to say that "Love is Power" but maybe that's what JKR meant. However, the Wand also stayed with Grindelwald for many years during WWII when atrocities were going on and he was in control, so love and the wand don't go together.
You are a fierce and loyal defender of Severus Snape, which is a good thing. What is it about the character of Professor Snape that resonates so deeply with you?
Oh wow - how do I keep this a short answer? "See my published works"? But seriously, what I really love about Snape is his perseverance, and that's no joke. He stays on track no matter what happens to him - pain, suffering, loss of love, anger, torture, humiliation at the hands of small children, you name it. He's an inspiration to me because we all feel weak and powerless, and I think he felt that way most of his life, but especially in the face of Voldemort. Then he found a way overcome his fears and literally stare down Voldemort. If that's not courage, I don't know what is.
Why do you think so many people misunderstand the character of Professor Snape?
I believe some people cannot look past his words and see the good intentions. In waiting so long for the series to end, people tricked themselves into buying the whole "ugly villain in black" persona that was actually debunked in the first book. If people want to see Snape as a funny cartoon character with sadistic tendencies, who am I to judge them? For me, though, he's a sensitive person who had to hide that all his life, first from his gruff father, then from bullies, and then from Voldemort and the other Death Eaters. I think Alan Rickman had the perfect description: "There's such still waters there." Yes, and still waters run deep.
Which of your marvelous essays here on HPN is your favorite, and why?
Probably the one about the Hippogriff symbolizing Snape's character, because Snape actually flew in Deathly Hallows, and that made me extremely happy!
Who is your second favorite character in the series?
It's a complete tossup between Luna and Neville. I love them for different reasons, Luna because she is so wise beyond her years and intuitive, and Neville because like Snape he also tries so hard to improve himself. I love it that Neville killed the snake that killed Snape. That's poetic justice.
If you could ask JK Rowling one question, or make one statement to her, what would that be?
It's not really one question, but a series of related questions. The main question I would ask her is whether she realizes the hypocrisy in calling Snape and Draco "bad boys," when obviously James and Sirius were just as bad. Why do Gryffindor students such as the Marauders, the Twins, and Ginny get a pass on bullying while others in Slytherin who do similar things are shown to be evil or ugly? Why does she glorify popularity and good looks if she wants people to look beneath appearances. Why is Slytherin still vilified in Deathly Hallows, and why did all the Gryffindors marry within their own House? She never blurred the lines between the Houses enough, and she never showed a positive side to Slytherin at all. That's a failure on her part, I think, and she'll be explaining it for years to come.
Since HP has finished, have you found any other series or books that you are excited about?
No, I'm not looking for another series and I really don't expect to find anything similar. I spent my teenage and post college years reading the Lord of the Rings trilogy over every year because nothing else appealed to me. And I had given up on fiction and certainly on criticism, since most modern novels seemed very negative to me. I think the HP phenomenon won't be duplicated in my lifetime. Twilight appealed to some of the same readers, but clearly the series fell short by the end because it lacked some of the integrity and literary roots that HP has.
Posted on: September 01, 2009, 05:46:39 PM
Yay, we're back!
Great answers, SIP!
If anyone's interested in being the Author for November, please contact me, or I'll just let this go until after the holidays. In fact, if any writer here would like to be in the Writer's Spotlight, please drop me a line. Thanks!